Ad: I Scored at Sam’s Club & My Football Party Kickin’ Buffalo Chicken Sandwich Recipe

buffalo chicken sandiwches
This shop has been compensated by Collective Bias, Inc. and Sam’s Club.  All opinions are mine alone.

football party recipe

My Vintage Football Party was a huge success!  I know I’m going to get tons of questions about where I found everything, and I’m excited to share a recipe with you all today for my Kickin’ Chicken Sandwich Recipe!

When we moved from Charlotte to Milwaukee, I have to say I was pretty darn excited to know that there was a Sam’s Club is nearby!  I had been a member for a long time when I lived in NC and rejoined when I moved to Milwaukee.  My sweet friend (and our talented photographer!), Michelle Kujawski, hadn’t been in a long time so I promised I’d take her on my hunt to find groceries, decor and an outfit to wear for my football party.  (People up here are die hard Packers fans!)  Let’s just say that she signed up for a membership after we spent 2 hours there having fun and shopping! Yay, I have a shopping buddy now.

So, I had decent size group to prep for, so I knew Sam’s would be the best value and I love the unique things they have versus the grocery store.

football sandwiches

It is funny how one product can trigger inspiration for an entire recipe.  Michelle and I were shopping around Sam’s Club trying to figure out what to make for the football party and I spotted these little adorable Bulillo Rolls! They were shaped JUST like footballs. Can you get any cuter?  They were PERFECT and I knew I had to come up with a football themed sandwich.  They were not only adorable but a big bag of the rolls cost me just under $5! Score!

I know everyone is obsessed with Chicken Wings, so I wanted to do my take on the Chicken Wings, but in a sandwich.  Let’s just say this Kickin’ Buffalo Chicken Sandwich scored me a lot of points with my guests!  I’m excited to share the easy and yummy recipe today!



Kickin’ Buffalo Chicken Sandwich Recipe:

– 4 Chicken Breasts
– 8 oz. Block of Cream Cheese
– 1 1/2 c. Buffalo Wing Sauce
– 3 T Butter
– 1 Packet Ranch Dressing Mix Powder
– Bulillo Rolls (Sam’s Club has the football shaped ones!)
– 6 c. Cole Slaw Mix (Sam’s Club Fresh Foods section)
– 1/2 c. (or more to your liking) Ranch Dressing (From a mix or store bought)
– 1/4 c. thin slices of celery
– Cheddar Cheese Slices
– Salt and Pepper to taste

Add your 4 chicken breasts, 1 packet of ranch seasoning and 1 Cup Buffalo Wing Sauce to a crock pot.  Cook your chicken in a crock pot on low.  (I start mine in the morning so by dinnertime it is nice and tender and easy to shred).  Once chicken is cooked, shred it and mix in the additional 1/2 c. Buffalo Wing Sauce and the 8 oz. block of cream cheese, and the 3 Tablespoons of butter.

Cole Slaw Topping:
Mix together 6 c. of cole slaw mix (we like the kind with the carrots) and 1/2c. Ranch Dressing and 1/4 c. thin slices of celery.  Add more ranch dressing, salt and pepper to taste.

Set your oven to 350 degrees.  Cut your Bulillo Rolls in half, lengthwise.  Add about 1/3 c. chicken mixture and add one slice of cheddar cheese on top.  Bake in the oven for 5-7 minutes, or until cheese has melted.  Remove from the oven and top with the celery cole slaw mixture and add the top bun.  Enjoy!

You do not have to melt the cheese on top, but we recommend it! If you have a large crowd, you can serve it in a crock pot and skip the toasting part!

chicken sandwich recipe



buffalo chicken sandiwches

What a fun and productive trip to Sam’s Club that was!  (Oh, and of course we found both soup bowls (for the chili we are making) and adorable Packers shirts there, too!)  I was all set for the big football party!

soup bowls

sams club shopping

buffalo chicken sandwiches


What favorite items do you love to find at Sam’s Club? We’d love to try something new! Fill us in!

Follow Sam’s Club on Facebook and Twitter.




  1. Wow, this sandwich has my name written all over it. I love shopping at Sam’s for fresh produce and meat…and now I need to add these rolls to the list! Thanks for sharing! #client

  2. Wow….those sandwiches look delicious! Can’t wait to visit Sam’s Club to find those football shaped rolls!
    How perfect it all looked! Will be trying the recipe real soon! Love the graphics for the Football party!

Comments are closed.